My siblings have opinions about Dad’s care, but I’m doing all the work. How can I get them to help?
How to turn their complaints into real help, and stop being the entire care plan.
I’m the eldest daughter, holding down the fort for my dad’s care in New York while my younger siblings live across the country in Seattle and LA. Dad (72) was diagnosed with Alzheimer’s a few months ago and was recently hospitalized after a fall. Mom isn’t strong physically and gets overwhelmed easily, so most of his care has fallen to me. I live nearby and have helped run the household since I was little, so on paper it makes sense. I guess some things never change, huh?
Don’t get me wrong: I love my dad, and if I had all the time in the world, I’d happily keep caring for my parents. But I don’t, and the cracks are starting to show. Work is intense, and there are only so many more weeks that my boss will let me work remotely from my parents’ apartment. It’s a miracle he’s allowed it this long, and I can’t lose my job.
My siblings aren’t helping. They call constantly, since everyone’s decided I’m in charge of Mom and Dad, and barrage me with questions and complaints about his care. My brother wants Dad in a care facility and fought me when I suggested an in-home aide. My sister says Mom and Dad seemed fine when she called, so she doesn’t get what the fuss is about.
I can’t keep being my parents’ full-time care manager and my siblings’ complaint department.
How do I get them to step up before I hit my breaking point? What can they even do from across the country?
Dear Holding Down the Fort in New York,
Well, it sounds like you’ve been promoted to family care manager, household coordinator, and sibling complaint department. Congratulations on the jobs nobody asked if you wanted!
Working with families, I often see the eldest daughter end up steering the ship while her siblings shout directions from shore. They may catch Dad during a good hour on the phone and think everything is fine. Meanwhile, you’re the one handling the appointments, the medication schedule, and the hard moments that never make it into those conversations, all while managing your own life.
And sometimes there’s more going on beneath the criticism. Your siblings may be scared, feeling guilty about being far away, or struggling to accept how much Dad’s needs have changed. When people feel helpless, they sometimes try to regain a little control by questioning the decisions someone else is making. Or maybe they’ve simply gotten used to you being the one who handles everything. Whatever the reason, their behavior doesn’t mean you have to keep carrying the entire load.
Turn opinions into action
Having an opinion about Dad’s care isn’t the same as helping provide it. It’s time to give your siblings an opportunity to do more than offer commentary from the sidelines.
The next time your brother suggests a care facility, ask him to research a few options, including costs, availability, and services. The Alzheimer’s Association is a great place for him to start learning about Dad’s changing needs and the different care options available. If he thinks a facility is the right move, he can help figure out what that would actually look like instead of adding another task to your plate.
If your sister thinks everything sounds fine, invite her to join Dad’s next doctor’s appointment by video, if he’s comfortable with it. Hearing directly from his healthcare team may help her better understand Dad’s needs and how she can help.
And when the suggestions keep coming, try putting some responsibility behind them:
“It sounds like you’re worried about how this is being handled. Is there a part of this you’d like to take over?”
Sometimes the most useful response to another opinion is an invitation to help. The goal isn’t to shut your siblings down, but to turn their concerns into something that actually lightens your load.
Remember, there’s a difference between asking someone to help with a task and asking them to own it. If you’re still making every list, assigning every task, and following up to make sure things get done, you’re still running the whole show, just with assistants. Instead, hand over a whole area. Your brother owns the insurance calls, start to finish. Your sister owns grocery deliveries. They become responsible for managing those tasks, not just waiting for you to tell them what to do next.
And when a conversation turns into another critique session, it’s okay to wrap it up. You’ve got enough to carry. One response to keep in your back pocket:
“I know you’re worried, and so am I. But unless we’re talking about what each of us can take on, this conversation isn’t helping anyone.”
Let’s talk about what’s sustainable
Here’s the part of your letter that concerns me most: you’re running out of time before your work arrangement has to change. Please don’t wait until your boss says you’ve run out of flexibility to plan for the long term. You need a plan that works while you work, not one that hinges on your all-day availability.
Since Alzheimer’s is progressive, Dad’s needs will change over time. This is a good opportunity to have a bigger conversation about what those changes might mean, what support may be needed, and how your family will handle them together.
Keep in mind that Dad and Mom still get a voice in all of this. An Alzheimer’s diagnosis doesn’t automatically take away his ability to participate in decisions about his life. Include him as much as he’s able, and make sure Mom’s wishes and limitations are part of the conversation, too.
To narrow things down, start with three questions: What does Dad want? What does he actually need to be safe? And what can your family realistically sustain, in time, energy, and money?
While your family is thinking this through, remember you also shouldn’t have to become an expert in Alzheimer’s care, insurance, and community resources just because you’re the daughter who lives closest.
This is where an experienced care management team can help. Hera’s care managers work with families to sort through the challenges they’re facing, find the right resources, and stay involved as your parent’s needs change. Instead of an all-you-can-eat buffet of possibilities, a care manager can bring you a carefully curated menu of realistic options to review together. Just as importantly, you’re not left coordinating every piece of the plan yourself.
Once you’ve identified some realistic options, it’s time for a family conversation that moves past who’s doing enough to how everyone’s needs are actually going to be met.
You might say: “I love Mom and Dad, and I’m going to continue being involved in their care. But I can’t keep providing this level of support and maintain my job. We need a plan for what they need now, what we might need down the road, who can take responsibility for what, and how we’re going to make it happen.”
Your limits are real, and you’re allowed to stop toughing it out.
You cannot be the entire care plan
You may never find the perfect words to make your siblings understand what you’re carrying, and you may not get the help you need from them. That’s a hard reality, but it doesn’t mean you’re out of options. Build a plan around the support that’s actually available, not the support you keep hoping will show up.
Being a good daughter doesn’t mean sacrificing your job, your health, or your own life to prove it.
You can love your parents with everything you’ve got without giving them everything you’ve got left.
– Noni
Have a question for Dear Hera?
We’d love to hear from you. Send it in here, and Noni might answer it in a future column.
Need support now?
Hera’s care managers, like Noni, take on the legwork of caregiving, from paperwork to medications to making sure your loved one gets to their follow-up appointments. They work alongside Hera’s clinicians and your loved one’s doctors to make sure nothing falls through the cracks.
For 90% of our families, care costs $0. We’ve had the honor of supporting over 2,000 families to date.
Learn more
Care manager
Noni, BSN, RN, is a Care Manager at Hera with over 20 years of nursing experience. She has also cared for a mother with dementia and a husband with ALS, and navigated serious health challenges of her own. Her perspective is shaped by working within the health system as a nurse and care manager, navigating it herself as a patient, and caring for loved ones as a family member. In Dear Hera, she offers families practical guidance, honest advice, and the reassurance that they don't have to figure everything out alone.
View profile
